Digital Processing

February 25th, 2013 | Uncategorized |

In the past several days, two contest-winning photographs have become fuel for a Blog world explosion of opinions on the ethics involved in digital post-processing and proper journalistic captioning.

This NPPA Ethics Blog is a compilation of a series of eMails as these two issues came to light over a number of days. The participants in this discussion were John Long, chair of the NPPA Ethics Committee; committee members Peter Southwick and Steve Raymer; and NPPA’s immediate past president Sean D. Elliot.

The first photograph in question is the World Press Photo of the Year 2012 by Paul Hansen which was thought by some critics to be over-processed. The second is a photograph from a story on Rochester, NY, by Paolo Pellegrin of Magnum, which came under fire after winning spots in both the World Press Photo contest and the POYi contest. Some of the people involved as subjects in the story and as Pellegrin’s assistants objected to the captioning and the conduct of the photographer when creating the image. Discussions on both these images are still developing.

Both photographs are included here:



John Long wrote: “Let me start with a short story – An old Vermonter tells a tale:

“Last night I was headed home on my sleigh. It was snowing a bit and it was cold. My horse was uncomfortable but I stopped for a few minutes checking out how the woods near my farm looked. But after a few idle thoughts, I went home because I had a bunch of things to do.”

“But Robert Frost tells it a little different:

“Whose woods these are I think I know.
His house is in the village though;
He will not see me stopping here
To watch his woods fill up with snow.

“My little horse must think it queer
To stop without a farmhouse near.
Between the woods and frozen lake
The darkest evening of the year.

“He gives his harness bells a shake
To ask if there is some mistake.
The only other sound’s the sweep
Of easy wind and downy flake.

“The woods are lovely, dark and deep
But I have promises to keep,
And miles to go before I sleep,
And miles to go before I sleep.

“The words of Robert Frost are so well structured, so full of meaning, so concise, so full of emotion. These are the words of a person who knows what he is doing with language and has total control of his craft.

“Here’s the point: all art is one. The principles that apply to one art form apply to all art forms. A good photographer has control of his craft, knows how to construct an image, process an image to tell the story he is telling. The truth is in the clarity of the emotion. The presence of the photographer is in every great photograph.

“All this is prologue to the question at hand – what are the limits to processing images?

“This has become a hot topic of late, especially in the wake of the discussions surrounding the WPP shot by Hansen that shows a procession through a narrow street in Gaza City. The image looks over-processed to some, overly digitally enhanced to the point of no longer looking real.

“When I started in the business in 1971 I learned how to print black-and-white in tones appropriate for reproduction on an old hot lead printing press. Quality prints on Agfa Portriga looked terrible in our newspaper (flat and dark) so we printed in high contrast and airbrushed like crazy. We burned the heck out of the corners and skies. It was how we practiced our craft in that age. When color came into general newspaper use, we had long discussions on whether Kodak or Fuji made the more accurate color negative film.

“Today the question is over-processing RAW and JPEG images. Ethically it comes down to making the images look as accurate as we can to the original scene, as we remember it.

“Of course, the mind is a terrible thing. How we remember color, light, how we frame and select details, how we feel about the subject, how we remember the temperature, the air quality, the smells and the sounds around us, is all part of how we print our photos. And all our images are liquid today because all images in a computer are liquid.

“There is a mythos around photography that a photograph IS reality. The older I get the more I see that photography is honest, yes – as honest as painting, as honest as poetry – which is a really good thing. But we have imbued our photographs with a sense we are looking at reality itself and not a human construct.

“Convention tells us that today honest photographs do not have burned in sky, for example. Convention tells us honesty today is non-glaring color, non-extreme contrast. To make rules regulating limits in processing is impossible. It evolves as the technology evolves. Photography is much more subjective than I used to believe.

“For many younger photojournalists the profession is moving beyond our old concepts of what constitutes honest photojournalism to a more subjective approach. It only maters that the photograph expresses my truth. Accuracy be damned. I will never be able to buy into that idea!!!

“We ask: What model are we holding our photographs to today? What is the ideal tonality, what are the limits of contrast and coloration? What is honesty in a photograph and when do we all agree a photographer has gone too far?

“Rather, the question should be: does this image convey a sense of the reality of the event? If the craftsmanship of the photographer helps us be present for the events he or she is observing, to see these events through his or her eyes, to feel as though we are present for history as it is being made, then the photograph is successful and honest. If we are distracted by elements in the picture that detract from our seeing through the photograph to the reality for which the photographer was present, then the picture is a lie.

“Conventions change, evolve, mutate. The English language Chaucer used is almost unintelligible today, yet it is still English. The meanings of words evolve, as does spelling and syntax. The same can be said of photography. No one prints like Stieglitz today; no one uses Autochrome to document news events. We laugh at our old prints from the 1970’s when we see how we used to use the Hand Of God printing on our best black-and-white images.

“Great craftsmen are masters of technique and tools of the trade. When I looked at Ansel Adams’ photographs of Yosemite I felt I really knew the place. I sensed the grandeur of the valley. I was surprised when I visited Yosemite that there was green in the trees and blue in the sky. Without thinking logically about it, I imagined Yosemite in black-and-white because of Ansel Adams. His art conveyed a sense of truth in a beautiful way where the technique did not call attention to itself or detract from the integrity of the image. All great art works this way, including photographic art.

“For me the bottom line is this: if the digital processing helps us read the image, if it helps us feel we are there with the photojournalist as history is happening around him or her, if we sense the photographer is showing us what was happening as accurately as possible, then the processing has done its job. The best processing is invisible; it fades into the background and lets the meaning come forward without calling attention to itself. If we find ourselves discussing how the photograph was printed rather than what it means, then the image is a failure.

“In the end we need to trust the photographer to bring us accurate, fair, and complete information and if he or she is a great craftsman, all the better. Today we are blessed with a number of phenomenal photographers who have mastered the new realities of digital photojournalism and, just as Robert Frost, e.e.cummings (sic) and Ezra Pound pushed the boundaries of language in their poetry, these photographers sometimes confuse us and challenge us to rethink ‘honesty.’: It is a wonderful sign of the vibrancy our profession.”

Steve Raymer wrote: “There is post-processing and there is post-processing. I feel strongly that in setting any standard in photojournalism, there needs to be room for the creative choices of a photographer. Just as we allow creative choices for print and broadcast journalists in HOW they would frame a story and/or tell that story – first person narrative, backing into a story with an anecdote, etc. – so, too, do photojournalists need freedom in how to present a job.

“Light, of course, is our single strongest storytelling element. And composition. And in today’s world, color. As I have said a million times, when I was a staff photographer at National Geographic, I would leave the office with four or five different Kodak and Fuji color transparency films. All would present the same subject in a different way in terms of contrast, saturation (intensity of a hue), color bias, etc. In today’s professional world, the overwhelming majority of magazine and documentary photographers shoot RAW files that need to be processed. In a RAW file there is nothing there but digital ones and zeroes (plus a crappy little JPEG preview). The photographer then needs to interpret their file, just as we had creative choice in the darkroom about what grade of paper on which to print a black-and-white image.

“I realize newspaper people shoot JPEG files in which the color processing is, by and large, done in the camera, not the computer. But please don’t negate or dismiss the prerogative of the photojournalist decide how to tell their story.”

Raymer also wrote: “I have seen a lot of chatter on social media about the winning image from Syria in the World Press Photo contest. My first reaction was the same as many, I suspect: Where is the strong side light coming from? The question remains, where do we draw the line? John Long once appeared in a video and talked about visual grammar, what was allowed in the darkroom in the days of film, etc and it all made sense. But we now have a generation and a half of photographers who never worked in the darkroom and, increasingly, their focus is not on the reader but on themselves and their creation. Would sure make a great round table discussion with representatives from industry, various news media, and a creative director thrown in for good measure.”

Peter Southwick wrote: “I have to admit I’m not that wound up about this one [Hansen’s World Press image]. I don’t see the processed version as being radically different from the other, and I don’t think it deceives or misinforms the viewer. If anything it makes it possible to see more clearly what’s in the photograph, and certainly it still qualifies as a moment.

“I’m not for a minute denying that there are issues to discuss when it comes to processing, whether this photograph or countless others. But once again I do a little thinking back to an earlier era that some people hold up as the high point of photojournalistic integrity. Those black-and-white, really grainy, high contrast, heavily dodged, hand-of-God burned images that were the standard then were no more ‘real’ than some processed images from this day and age. I recently looked back at a few contest books from the 1970′s and early 1980′s, and it’s pretty appalling what won prizes then. Suffice it to say it was no golden age.

“Absolutely, we should continue to talk about and debate the appropriateness of using the tools we have in our hands now, but for me the bottom line is always going to be: did we inform the viewer/reader without confusion or deception?

“This photo, a clearly outstanding image, works for me in either version.”

Southwick also wrote: “One aspect I would like to see added to our debate on all of this is the expectations and level of knowledge of the viewing/reading audience. They haven’t stood still all these years, and they are much more up to speed on what can be done to photographs than we might suspect. Based on my unscientific research (asking people!), they know a great deal about Photoshop etc., and they expect that whatever they are looking at has been “processed” to some degree. However, this doesn’t mean they don’t necessarily trust what they see. They just assume that’s part of the photographic process, and they are more sophisticated than we think when it comes to seeing the reality of the image past the special effects.

“I think that younger people (I’m talking general population, not professional photographers) not only don’t pay much attention to this issue, they really don’t think it matters. It’s just part of their world, and there is no way time is going to run backwards to an era when this didn’t exist.

“The bottom line is that photojournalism is produced for a mass market (we hope) and the thoughts of those on the receiving end matter. Once again, I’m not for a minute saying this isn’t important. The fundamentals of photojournalism will always matter, and images that deliver information without deception or misinformation are always the goal. We need to keep talking about where those lines are drawn, even if they are constantly in motion. But we also have to make sure we don’t marginalize these conversations to the point that they will only resonate with a small number of veteran photojournalists.”

Sean D. Elliot wrote: “This is my latest missive on the discussion raging on the Photojournalists Cooperative Facebook group: All I can say is that if I turned in a caption that was that lacking in detail my boss would rip me a new one … and then if the subject of the photograph called when it was published to say I’d got such basic facts wrong … I might not sit for a week … figuratively. Even if this were only a case of sloppy journalism (and I’m sorry, it sure looks like a little more than that to me) it still is an example of why standards are so important. It’s why I’ve spent the last decade-plus of my life pushing the NPPA and its Code Of Ethics and the role of a cohesive professional community in creating and upholding standards.

“The photojournalism world has become so fractured, so scattered. We all work via remote … we don’t work in an office, our photo editors have been laid-off (or if not downsized then carrying such a workload as to be ineffective at editing) … our staffs, if they exist, are smaller and busier.

“I’m blown-away by the length and passion of this thread … it’s more of what we need. This discussion needs to have legs. Photojournalists all over the world need to be thinking about these things. Students need to be taught these issues, professionals need to think about them every day.

“Journalism is being diluted by increased workloads, reliance on handouts and citizen submissions … whether we are talking about established western democracies or emerging ones, the vitality of a free press is so important. Visual reporting is part of that mix and it must be seen as fair, accurate, ethical and thoughtful. We can’t parachute into places just because we think it might be interesting. We need journalists in our communities who can tell the stories and spread them to a wider audience. The journalists in Rochester are the ones who ought to be telling that story. Maybe they’re not because they’ve been downsized into submission … but the solution is not to bring-in outsiders, the solution is to find the model that allows for serious, ethical, professional journalist to do their work in their communities.

“This incident is a symptom … the disease is far bigger than Paolo Pellegrin and his Rochester jaunt.”


62 Responses to “Digital Processing”

  1. I am not confident how the “W21 rally wheels are “rarely seen today” 50 the Mopars built in that era appeared to obtain them and in some cases extra wear them now. I received a laugh from “rare factory Slick Top”. So it isn’t going to possess a vinyl roof large offer.

  2. I took these pictures of a step-down Hudson pickup within a Maine junkyard in the early 1970s. I recall that it looked extremely properly accomplished… as if created because of the factory. I believe that that it had faded markings indicating that it had been applied by a dealership in Everett Massachusetts. At the time any vehicle could be experienced for $25. Sadly if the price of scrap went up a portable crusher was brought in.

  3. Views and Prayers going out to your Family and Friends of Major Jim…God Bless!

  4. Boka tid direkt via webben på länken nedan. Du kommer att se lediga tider för 45 dagar framåt. Är tiderna slut? Du kan ringa oss eller maila oss.

  5. elanat Afghanistan is a free and open source web analytics application written by a team of international developers that runs on a PHP/MySQL webserver. elanat Afghanistan is used by …

  6. آوین چت یکی از قدیمی ترین چت روم های فارسی ایرانی میباشد و فقط کافیست یکبار امتحان کنید تا از اینترنت و گفتگوی مجازی لذت ببرید.

  7. I genuinely enjoyed talking about the car with Jay but this movie can be a good reminder as to why I am not from the entertainment organization.

  8. I want to get across my appreciation for your generosity supporting all those that require help with this particular study. Your very own dedication to getting the message all-around turned out to be especially informative and have truly enabled folks much like me to achieve their aims. Your entire helpful guideline implies so much a person like me and much more to my colleagues. With thanks; from each one of us.

  9. I

  10. This actually answered my drawback, thank you!

  11. A fascinating discussion!

  12. You made some first rate factors there. I regarded on the internet for the difficulty and found most individuals will go along with along with your website.

  13. Electronic equipment are now readily available that will acquire blood stress from the upper arm, wrist, or finger. Whilst the use of the more distal internet sites might be a lot more easy, measurement of blood pressure from the arm (brachial artery) has always been the typical process and is most likely to continue to be so for the foreseeable potential. The actuality that a system has passed the validation requirements does not assure precision in the unique affected individual, and it is crucial that each device be checked on each individual affected person right before the readings are accepted as getting legitimate (see the prior area on Validation of Screens).

  14. Heya i am for the first time here. I came across this board and I find It really useful & it helped me out much. I hope to give something back and help others like you aided me.

  15. Very interesting subject, thanks for putting up.

  16. One thing is that often one of the most common incentives for using your credit cards is a cash-back as well as rebate present. Generally, you’re going to get 1-5 back for various buying. Depending on the cards, you may get 1 again on most purchases, and 5 back on expenditures made from convenience stores, gas stations, grocery stores plus ‘member merchants’.

  17. Thank you for the auspicious writeup. It in fact was a amusement account it. Look advanced to more added agreeable from you! By the way, how could we communicate?

  18. I like what you guys are up too. Such smart work and reporting! Keep up the superb works guys I’ve incorporated you guys to my blogroll. I think it will improve the value of my website :) .

  19. I loved as much as you’ll receive carried out right here. The sketch is tasteful, your authored subject matter stylish. nonetheless, you command get bought an nervousness over that you wish be delivering the following. unwell unquestionably come further formerly again since exactly the same nearly a lot often inside case you shield this hike.

  20. I

  21. Good

  22. Would you be thinking about exchanging links?

  23. You actually make it seem really easy along with your presentation however I in finding this topic to be really something which I think I might by no means understand. It kind of feels too complex and very vast for me. I am looking ahead on your subsequent put up, I

  24. I

  25. Can I just say what a comfort to find a person that really knows what they’re talking about online.

  26. For anyone who is interested in the environmental hardships, it could gift all of them are aware that to bring about merely one field hard far more than a bit flowing shoots reasoning greater liters pertaining to oil and gas to bring about. dc free mommy weblog giveaways family trip home gardening house power wash baby laundry detergent

  27. With every thing that seems to be building within this area, a significant percentage of viewpoints are actually very stimulating. On the other hand, I appologize, because I can not give credence to your whole plan, all be it exhilarating none the less. It would seem to everyone that your comments are actually not completely rationalized and in reality you are generally your self not even entirely convinced of the point. In any event I did appreciate examining it.

  28. It’s awesome for me to have a web page, which is beneficial in support
    of my know-how. thanks admin

  29. This business is among the greatest recipients
    of the uses of reagents. Our palates have become more
    sophisticated, so just using salt and pepper isn’t going to be enough anymore.
    If you must freeze it or put it in the fridge, at least use a freezer bag.

  30. This is my first time pay a quick visit at here and i am in fact impressed
    to read everthing at one place.

  31. Link exchange is nothing else however it is simply placing the other
    person’s webpage link on your page at suitable place and other person will also do similar in favor of

  32. Link exchange is nothing else except it is just placing the other person’s blog link on your page at proper place and other person will also
    do same in favor of you.

  33. Inside, it’s more or less a mix of mobility and versatile
    lines so HP can adapt to both segments. A VPN is one of
    the best ways to have remote access to your home machine and maintain a secure network connection while using highly insecure public Wi-fi hotspots.
    The groups behind the new venture, along with Mc – Kinney, believe
    that the pioneering initiative will also encourage
    new ideas and growth from entrepreneurs and the business community.

  34. Stationery, cards and stamps put together in a basket would be another useful gift.
    This gift would give more of a classy, elegant and traditional feeling.
    Frequently, one marriage partner will care much more about the anniversary than their husband or

  35. Heya i’m for the first time here. I found this board and
    I find It really useful & it helped me out much. I hope
    to give something back and aid others like you
    helped me.

  36. I Һave read so many posts concerning the blogher lovers howеver this paragraph
    is actually a fastidious paгagraph, ҟeep it

  37. Great blog but honestly the sheer amount of Ads.

  38. la evento passare in estremamente di loro individuo il ha ore al di
    proprio che fattori

  39. -Atlantic City Classic Car Show & Auction – February
    24 through February 26 in Atlantic City, NJ.
    This software was examined and located engaged on many operating
    systems that like Home windows XP,Windows Vista, Windows 7,
    and Mac OS X. You can either play in career mode or as a quick race.

  40. Replacing your old windows with new energy efficient windows
    can cut your heating and cooling costs by as much as 50 percent.
    It all depends on how good you are at knowing what is more effective.
    ll need to know that replacing windows may require extra construction on your home,
    so that you can replace windows into the proper sized openings.

  41. I think you have observed some very interesting points , thankyou for the post.

  42. Company name: Painting Contractors Cape Town
    Address: Edgemead Business Park, Edgemead drive, Edgemead drive, Cape Town 7460
    Phone:082 376 1226

  43. Remember that in a single way or any other, your tattoo represents about yourself, too.
    It was long time back when, women and men was required to locate sources to watch out for sex partners.
    One in the many pleasures of every day life is sex that
    is certainly enjoyed by one and.

  44. Thanks for finally talking about > Ethics Matters

  45. Thanks for finally talking about > Ethics Matters

  46. Thank you, I have just been looking for info approximately this subject for a while and yours is
    the greatest I’ve came upon so far. But, what concerning the
    bottom line? Are you certain about the supply?

  47. I am impressed with this website , very I am a fan .

  48. I visited various blogs but the audio feature for audio songs current at
    this web page is truly wonderful.

    Also visit my homepage

  49. descenso del sella

  50. The highly recommended Admiral Rodney, well worth
    the stroll through the town to Dean Street. Following the Second World War in 1948, Shostakovich had to endure his second denunciation by the Communist
    Party as a result of the Zhdanov decree. Ignore Top 11 Chop Prime 12 soccer Top Eleven Football Manager Tokens
    Hack [] boss Bridal party crack top eleven compromise generator at the

  51. I always spent my half an hour to read this webpage’s articles everyday along with
    a cup of coffee.

  52. You are a very clever person!

  53. He bought a bigger stove to take care of his trade.

    If this is the case then this restaurant will
    generally make a great cup of restaurant quality coffee that you may want to recreate at home.
    In response, Chen Xiao rather said: “The merger with Dazhong is proceeding smoothly, the media actually reported Yongle layoffs follow-up to the merger, mainly for medium and large business areas coincide with the Beijing-Tianjin region Management Positions to optimize the personnel involved may reach 10%.

  54. asks blog sites to shut down – July 25, 2010, San Francisco Chronicle (San Francisco’s leading newspaper). They forget that they are not taking good care of their health , mostly their breast health. filed by Actos users who say the drug caused them to develop bladder cancer and other serious side effects.

  55. ? Wystarczy być inteligentny o cokolwiek ? re także robi,?
    on szczepy

  56. Touche. Outstanding arguments. Keep up the amazing spirit.

  57. maszyna do gry na pieniadze

  58. Some truly superb information, Gladiolus I noticed this. “Without discipline, there’s no life at all.” by Katharine Hepburn.

  59. Good

  60. You are my intake , I have few web logs and sometimes run out from to brand.

  61. gra za prawdziwe pieniadze

  62. My programmer is trying to convince me to move to .net from
    PHP. I have always disliked the idea because of the costs.
    But he’s tryiong none the less. I’ve been using WordPress on a variety of websites for about a year and
    am nervous about switching to another platform. I have heard great things about
    Is there a way I can transfer all my wordpress content into it?
    Any kind of help would be really appreciated!

Leave a Reply