August 10th, 2012 by Justice Warren and tagged Access, Arrest, first amendment, free speech, journalism, Legal, Mickey Osterreicher, national press photographers association, NPPA, photography, photojournalism, photojournalist, police, police relations, recording
The American News and Information Services (ANIS) filed a Complaint Wednesday in federal district court seeking redress for the repeated violation of the First Amendment rights of an ANIS employee by San Diego City and County government officials.
The complaint alleges that San Diego law enforcement exhibited a pattern of First Amendment rights violations by giving law enforcement officers excessive discretion to prevent access to and recording of public safety activity. It also alleges that the pattern is further evidenced by the San Diego Police Department’s (SDPD) exclusive authority to issue media credentials and the retaliatory actions taken against those who attempt to exercise their right to record.
“The SD Defendants, despite a revolution in access to news brought on by rapid technological advances, still seek through the use of government-issued press credentials control of the message through control of the messenger,” the complaint states.
James C. Playford, a National Press Photographers Association (NPPA) member who began work for ANIS after the SDPD refused to renew his press credentials, has been arrested four times since 2010 while attempting to cover public safety activities. Three of those arrests resulted in the seizure of Playford’s equipment and raw video. A photo and physical description of Playford was also allegedly disseminated to San Diego law enforcement identifying him as an individual prohibited from access to public safety activity.
San Diego law enforcement agencies have come under fire recently due to repeated arrests of photojournalists. The NPPA sent a letter to the SDPD and along with one from the American Civil Liberties Union of San Diego and Imperial County (ACLU) which they referenced on their website, requesting an end to police interference with photojournalists’ rights to record events occurring in public. Wednesday’s letter was NPPA’s third letter to San Diego law enforcement this year concerning the rights of photojournalists.
“While the press may not have any greater access rights than the public to these incidents, they have no less rights either,” said Mickey H. Osterreicher, general counsel for NPPA, in his letter to the SDPD. “Unfortunately a number of your officers have abused their discretion in limiting those press rights and then have detained and arrested our members when questioned about such discriminatory acts.”
In the most recent media controversy, NPPA member and freelance photojournalist Edward Baier was arrested on July 20th by the SDPD and charged with interfering with a police officer, though Baier claimed he was attempting to film from private property with the owner’s permission. Baier said he was tackled by two officers during the altercation, causing him injuries requiring medical attention.
Baier’s arrest was his second this year by the SDPD. In January, police told Baier to move away from the scene of a drowning, though the public was allowed to remain inside of the police tape. When Baier protested, he was arrested and charged with resisting arrest. The arresting officers later added two counts of assaulting an officer.
“The reliance by your officer to question, detain, interfere with, arrest and seize the property of someone engaged in a lawful activity under color of law is reprehensible,” Osterreicher said in his January letter to the SDPD. “At best, behavior that chills free speech and unreasonably seizes property is extremely unprofessional, at worst it is criminal.”
Posted in Access, ACLU, ACLU of Dan Diego & Imperial County, Assault on Photographers, Attack Photographers, confiscated, First Amendment, First Amendment rights, Lawsuit, National Press Photographers Association, Newsgathering, NPPA, photographers, Photographers' Rights, photojournalism, Recording Police, San Diego Police Department, SDPD | No Comments »