Search

Additional Comments Filed by NPPA and Other Groups Following Orphan Works Roundtables

May 27th, 2014 by Tyler Wilson and tagged , , , , , , , , , , ,

Additional comments were filed by the National Press Photographers Association (NPPA) on May 20, 2014 on the issue of Orphan Works and Mass Digitization, as a follow-up to roundtable discussions held by the U.S. Copyright Office in Washington, DC on March 10-11, 2014. (See: http://www.copyright.gov/orphan/transcript/0310LOC.pdf and http://www.copyright.gov/orphan/transcript/0311LOC.pdf for transcripts of day 1 and 2 of those discussions).

The filing by NPPA supplemented additional post-roundtable comments submitted by the Digital Medial Licensing Association (PACA) on behalf of the Professional Photographers of America (PPA), the American Photographic Artists, Inc. (APA), the American Society Of Media Photographers (AMSP), the Graphic Artists Guild (GAG) as well as NPPA) in response to a Notice of Inquiry issued by the U.S. Copyright Office in February,  2014. These most recently submitted comments expanded on initial comments (submitted by NPPA to the Register on January 24, 2013).

The comments primarily responded to discussions at the round table from stakeholders who think that orphan works legislation is no longer necessary given their increased reliance on the doctrine of fair use. It is the position of the NPPA that, while the doctrine of fair use can be used as an affirmative defense, it is certainly is not broadly available to allow the use of photos without permission, credit or compensation. “This one size fits all approach appears to be what is turning Title 17 law on its head with copyright now becoming the exception to fair use. Rather than conducting a proper balancing of the four fair use factors, a number of courts have made such ruling once they determine that a use is transformative. NPPA asserts that this type of analysis was never intended to be applied as the sole determinative element in making a fair use ruling in an individual copyright infringement case, let alone in one involving mass digitization of millions of works,” wrote NPPA general counsel Mickey H. Osterreicher and advocacy committee chair Alicia Wagner Calzada (who is also an attorney) in their jointly drafted comments.

The problem of social media websites automatically stripping out any and all identifying metadata when images are uploaded to their sites, thus creating instant orphans of contemporary work, is also “an issue that needs to be addressed more seriously and, once properly resolved, would help rectify most of the orphan works concerns expressed by users,” the NPPA comments concluded.

Posted in copyright, copyright infringement, National Press Photographers Association, NPPA, Orphan Works, photographers, photojournalism, U.S. Copyright Office | 3 Comments »



3 Responses to “Additional Comments Filed by NPPA and Other Groups Following Orphan Works Roundtables”

  1.   Larue Olivarres Says:

    This will be challenging for yourself and for all of us for your factors you mentioned. An attractive place, a beautiful lifestyle, a beautiful memory. I’ll pass up all the things that place represented, especially the people today that produced it what it was. I love you my sweet.

  2.   Catrice Ruhl Says:

    .superior! Log in just toward Response

  3.   Greg Tade Says:

    I simply wished to say thanks yet again. I do not know what I would have made to happen without those thoughts revealed by you directly on that problem. It had become the difficult setting in my view, nevertheless looking at a new well-written tactic you treated that made me to jump over joy. I am just happy for the work and then hope that you comprehend what a powerful job your are carrying out educating the mediocre ones thru a blog. Most likely you have never got to know all of us.

Leave a Reply