New York Lawmakers Urged to Allow Cameras In The Courtroom

January 4th, 2014 by Wills Citty and tagged , , , , , , ,

As a new legislative session approaches, the NPPA is hopeful that the New York State legislature will finally permit cameras in the courtroom. To that end, the NPPA drafted a letter signed by 36 media organizations, to Governor Andrew Cuomo expressing its support for expanded audiovisual coverage of courtroom proceedings.

There’s evidence that the tide is already turning on the issue in New York.  In a speech last year, New York Court of Appeals Chief Judge Jonathan Lippman announced a legislative proposal to expand camera coverage of courtroom proceedings.  Ultimately, however, it is the legislature’s prerogative to establish more permissive access laws.  The benefits from such a move would be significant, explained NPPA General Counsel Mickey Osterreicher:

“It will bring transparency to the judicial system, provide increased accountability from litigants, judges, and the press and educate citizens about the judicial process. Audio-visual coverage will allow the public to ensure that proceedings are conducted fairly, and, by extension, that government systems are working correctly.  We expect that the watchful eye of the public will demand increased accountability from all courtroom participants. Claims of sensationalistic or inaccurate reporting will be readily verifiable by a public able to view the underlying proceedings for itself.”

Osterreicher pointed to a series of empirical studies and experiments that tend to refute claims that audiovisual equipment is obtrusive and hinders defendant’s fair trial rights. The evolution of both audiovisual equipment and broadcast media stands at the core of the discussion.  Simply put, the traditional justifications offered for banning cameras from the courtroom are no longer a concern.

“There are no more whirling, noisy cameras. There are no more glaring lights.  Nor does a thundering herd of technicians have to go in and out of the courtroom to set up and tear down their gear.  Modern equipment is inaudible, requires no additional lighting and can be operated by a limited number of trained professionals,” noted Osterreicher. Further, “their presence in the courtroom and the images that they convey provide a compelling public service without infringing upon the constitutional or statutory rights of any affected persons or institutions. Respect for the dignity, decorum and safety of the courthouse is not only maintained but enhanced by having cameras in the courtroom,” he said.

The expansion of cable broadcasting and the Internet is also critical, as media groups are now free from time and programming constraints and can often show live feeds of courtroom proceedings from start to finish.

Osterreicher added that any legislation should allow judges the discretion necessary to permit cameras while preserving the rights of litigants and the sanctity of the courtroom.

The desirability of the free exchange of ideas is one of the foundational tenants of the First Amendment.  As such, lawmakers should look closely at the rationale for any policy that places a bottleneck on the flow of information, Osterreicher said.

“Society can ill afford to let the arbitrary and speculative objections of some antagonistic to the electronic press infringe upon the public’s right to observe proceedings in our courts by lens-capping the very means by which modern society receives news and information.”

Numerous states have considered measures similar to those contemplated in New York, and Congress has even considered passing legislation to reverse the longtime ban on cameras in the Supreme Court, the most recent effort stalling in Senate committee last June.

The NPPA had previously submitted an amicus brief to the New York State Court of Appeals supporting cameras in the courtroom the last time this issue came before the court in 2005.

Posted in Access, Cameras, Cameras in the Courtroom, First Amendment, First Amendment rights, Legal, National Press Photographers Association, News Photography, Newsgathering, NPPA, photographers, Photographers' Rights, photojournalism | 55 Comments »

55 Responses to “New York Lawmakers Urged to Allow Cameras In The Courtroom”

  1.   Kayce Mcginity Says:

    Awfully illuminating thank you, I do think your current visitors may perhaps want a whole lot more material such as this continue the great effort.

  2.   log sheds factory Says:

    Pleasant website , very fashion and design and style , extremely neat and make use of relaxing.

  3.   Habibi Says:

    Thank you for the excellent writeup. It in fact was a amusement account it. Appear advanced to far added agreeable from you! Even so, how could we communicate?

  4.   iOS tworzenie aplikacji Says:

    I am typically to running a blog and i actually appreciate your content. The article has really peaks my interest. I am going to bookmark your website and hold checking for brand spanking new information.

  5.   Saul Stormes Says:

    Brilliant short article many thanks! Seems to perform perfectly well together with the latest versions of wordpress as well (3.3)Made the code a lot cleaner as mentioned and seems to have made life simpler when trying to implement the comments form into side areas ect. (Had a nightmare with previous use of the normal code)

  6.   Glenn Justinger Says:

    I was recommended this website by my cousin. I’m not sure whether this post is written by him as nobody else know such detailed about my difficulty. You’re wonderful! Thanks!

  7.   Anonymous Says:

    Forex investing is the trading of forex in the international exchange industry (Fx or Forex) which is a world-wide marketplace for the trading of currency in an intention to make revenue. The international trade market place determines the relative worth of every single currency with respect to an additional forex. The hazards included in forex trading is extremely higher due to lot of unpredictability, but a amount of traders have produced enormous sums of money in forex buying and selling particularly Monthly bill Lipschitz, George Soros and Stanley Druckenmiller. It is controlled by the forex trading forex buying and selling board possessing the requisite jurisdiction.

  8.   Michael Kristen Says:

    I wanted to inform you, I do believe there exists a trouble with the RSS, its not showing properly in my RSS viewer. It simply began last week, did you alter something on the blog?

  9.   name Says:

    Proteins account for to of dried green coffee seeds.A majority of the proteins are of the of -S-storage kind alpha component ofkDa, beta – ,

  10.   Hae Morel Says:


  11.   Wilber Blaser Says:

    At any [b]prednisone and asprin for dog[/b] tightly that a fundamental euthyroidism is achieved, two mobile patisents of pentostatin are recommended.

  12.   Seth Says:

    Thanks for calling

  13.   Vida Says:


  14.   nogood87 Says:

    I love the theatre

  15.   name Says:

    majority of the samples we reviewed this month were prepared using this straightforward approach.,

  16.   name Says:

    for centuries, and has utilised simple methods such as roasting in cast iron skillets over a wood fire and hand-turning small steel drums on a kitchen ,

  17.   Tod Sboro Says:

    You are such a rock star. But after days of dingos and desert and rock and heat, not much is gonna throw you off. Good job

  18.   Lacie Shipps Says:

    Thank you for keeping us updated. I really appreciate it Thank you.

  19.   telecharger doodle jump Says:

    It’s really very complicated in this full of activity life tto listen news on Television, so I simply use internet for that reason,
    and obtaun the hottest news.

  20.   name Says:

    dry and tartly sweet, a structure we might expect from a wet-processed coffee, though the intense chocolate-toned richness I suspect derives from the ,

  21.   name Says:

    produce higher yields, but requires the clearing of trees and increased use of fertilizer and pesticides, which damage the environment and cause health ,

  22.   name Says:

    total production, in. million , in ,million bags . Coffee is then of the country’s exports. The gains made by this trade ,

  23.   name Says:

    harmful effects of coffee consumption. Furthermore, results and generalizations are complicated by differences in age, gender, health status, and serving ,

  24.   Hunter Says:

    About a year

  25.   Zoey Says:

    I’d like to cancel this standing order

  26.   name Says:

    Most treatment plans for urticaria involve being aware of one’s triggers, but this can be difficult, since several forms of urticaria are known and people ,

  27.   name Says:

    Australia (listed as a Schedule prescription drug),

  28. Says:

    You have noted very interesting details! ps nice internet site.

  29.   Sofa Bed Says:


  30.   Office Decorating Ideas Says:

    I like what you guys are up too. Such clever work and reporting! Keep up the superb works guys I have incorporated you guys to my blogroll. I think it will improve the value of my web site :)

  31.   Modern Dining Room Says:


  32.   Anonymous Says:


  33.   name Says:

    infections, viral infections, parasitic infections, or autoimmune problems such as inflammatory bowel diseases. It can also be caused by tuberculosis, colon ,

  34.   name Says:

    lips or on the skin around the mouth to be included under the general term oral ulceration (e.g. an ulcer left by rupture of a blister caused by herpes ,

  35.   name Says:

    cells with fast turnovers such as malignant cells. However, the epithelia of the mouth also has a high turnover rate and makes oral ulceration a common side ,

  36.   Clean Energy Says:

    You made some decent points there. I did a search on the issue and found most persons will approve with your website.

  37.   BusinessInsurance Says:

    Hello. remarkable job. I did not imagine this. This is a fantastic story. Thanks!

  38.   Earleen Schauwecker Says:

    An unputdownable language is designer interpret. I suppose that you simply need to write statesman on this subject, it might not be described as a taboo master but generally folks usually are not ample to communicate on such topics. To your succeeding. Cheers like your Customized Denver Area Truck Fleet Washing.

  39.   Trudy Pedralba Says:

    Your prize for 1st position is from the garden sir, decide on an apple from the tree and there will likely be a note inside, the note will lead you to some snake, the snake will talk to you and inform you exactly where to go next, you will then construct a giant ship and save all dwelling creatures in the rainfall, you will drop from the ship, but do not stress a massive fish will save you and you will dwell inside it for seven days. Immediately after the seven days you will obtain your solution to a mans house, the mans title is Job, convey to him that he’s a bastard and that you also won the prize, following he offers you the prize, get rid of him to prove your gratitude.

  40.   name Says:


  41.   freeman Says:

    What sort of music do you listen to? what is trazodone 473 DUR/PPS Code Counter N 1 variable O This will be a counter of each

  42.   name Says:

    K-Cups were the first single-cup drip-style system in the market and continue to dominate the escalating growth of convenience-first single-cup brewing. When ,

  43.   name Says:

    of coffee and sail transport in the early days of coffee and also perhaps a little challenging technically, given the ease with which green coffee succumbs ,

  44.   name Says:

    blend to CancerCare, a national non-profit that provides free support services for those affected by cancer diagnosis. The blend was inspired by Amy ,

  45.   mobile application development in kolkata Says:

    1. mobile application development in kolkata :

  46.   heel spur Says:

    Vi kan behandla benhinneinflammation med stötvågsbehandling, tejpning och rehabträning. ortorehab

  47.   Peter beck Says:


  48.   gacuk ruhture Says:

    I like this post, enjoyed this one regards for posting. “Pain is inevitable. Suffering is optional.” by M. Kathleen Casey.

  49.   Cathrine Spender Says:

    Quite beneficial, look forwards to coming back

  50.   5shadesreseller Says:

    One thing is the fact that one of the most popular incentives for making use of your credit cards is a cash-back as well as rebate present. Generally, you will get 1-5 back on various expenses. Depending on the card, you may get 1 back again on most acquisitions, and 5 back on acquisitions made at convenience stores, filling stations, grocery stores and also ‘member merchants’.

  51.   prestige falcon city location Says:


  52.   Kirk Steider Says:

    Thank you for the auspicious writeup. It in fact was a amusement account it. Look advanced to more added agreeable from you! By the way, how can we communicate?

  53.   Toney Theriot Says:

    I have to voice my appreciation for your kind-heartedness in support of men and women that need help on this area of interest. Your special dedication to getting the message throughout had become exceptionally productive and have always helped associates just like me to get to their desired goals. Your new useful hints and tips means a great deal a person like me and even more to my peers. Thanks a lot; from all of us.

  54.   Marlena Buchholtz Says:

    I loved as much as you’ll receive carried out right here. The sketch is attractive, your authored subject matter stylish. nonetheless, you command get bought an nervousness over that you wish be delivering the following. unwell unquestionably come more formerly again as exactly the same nearly very often inside case you shield this increase.

  55.   Classified Ads Says:

    Hi there, just became aware of your blog through Google, and found that it is truly informative. I

Leave a Reply