NPPA Joins in Brief Supporting Photographer in Pivotal Copyright Case

December 18th, 2013 by Wills Citty and tagged , , , ,

The NPPA joined several other photographer and writer advocacy groups today in filing legal documents urging a New York judge to find that an artist who used a photographer’s images in art exhibits without permission did so in violation of copyright law.The decision in the case represents a test of a key legal doctrine, and will hopefully both clarify and place a reasonable limit on the “fair use” defense, which allows use of an otherwise copyrighted work for criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, or research.

In 2007 and 2008, artist Richard Prince altered and incorporated 30 of Patrick Cariou’s pictures into paintings and collages displayed in St. Barth’s and New York City.  Cariou captured the images, which appeared originally in his Yes Rasta collection, over the course of six years living amongst Rastafarians in Jamaica.  When Cariou discovered Prince’s work, he sued the artist for copyright infringement.

Prince defended the 2008 suit under the fair use doctrine, arguing that by incorporating the images into a new context, a collage or painting, he had “transformed” the pictures sufficiently to claim fair use. A U.S District Court judge disagreed, holding that the art did not transform the images in a manner that was meant to critique or otherwise comment on them.

The district court’s decision was almost completely overturned earlier this year, when the Second Circuit of the U.S. Court of Appeals found the lower court had applied an incorrect legal standard.

The court found that “[t]he law imposes no requirement that a work comment on the original or its author in order to be considered transformative” and that 25 of the photographs Prince used were protected as fair use.  The remaining five images presented “closer questions” the court said, as alterations to their physical appearance was minimal. See earlier NPPA story here.

The question of whether or not a work is “transformative” is central to a fair use analysis, the court noted, as transformative works … lie at the heart of the fair use doctrine’s guarantee of breathing space.”  Applying an inclusive definition of the doctrine, the court found that a work could qualify as fair use even if it is not one of the aforementioned uses included in the copyright statute. The Second Circuit found that all that is required is that the work communicates “new expression, meaning, or message.”

Now, as the District Court prepares to reconsider copyright claims related to the remaining five works, the NPPA along with the American Photographic Artists, American Society of Journalists and Authors, American Society of Media Photographers, Graphic Artists Guild, Jeremy Sparig, Picture Archive Council Of America and Professional Photographers of America have all joined in amicus brief in support of Patrick Cariou in that the defendants in this case have not met their burden under the fair use defense with regard to the five paintings being considered on remand. 

NPPA General Counsel Mickey Osterreicher articulated this position in an affidavit to the court as part of the brief drafted by attorney David Leichtman of the law firm of Robins, Kaplan, Miller & Ciresi, LLP. “If a lawsuit is brought [under the Second Circuit’s standard] , original photographers seem to be facing a judicial system that continues to eviscerate their rights as copyright holders by ruling more and more unlicensed derivative uses as “fair use,”” Osterreicher said, “However, fair use was not meant to be an offensive assertion permitting infringers to believe that they have the right to misappropriate and infringe on copyright holders’ rights with complete immunity.”

Osterreicher also noted that a broad interpretation of the fair use defense threatens critical economic models of the photography industry, and categorically protecting works like Prince’s from claims of infringement sets a dangerous precedent.

“Along with inclusion in various media, NPPA members make images available for licensing for uses such as those of the works created by Prince. If Prince needed an image of Jamaica, or Rastafarians, these images could have been, and should have been, lawfully licensed easily and for the appropriate standard license fees,” Osterreicher said, adding, “Any image has the potential to be licensed for multiple purposes. To isolate ‘art reference’ or ‘art’ as special classes of use that no longer require any licensing, weakens the licensing model and opens the door to more and more unlicensed uses.”

Appropriately cabining the fair use defense is especially important today, in an environment where monitoring infringements is increasingly difficult, and their economic toll continues to mount.

“NPPA members must shoulder the burden of policing infringements while at the same time seeking and fulfilling photographic assignments, working on self-initiated projects and maintaining all of the tasks of running a 24/7 business. For many, losses due to infringement have been devastating,” Osterreicher said.

The NPPA will continue to monitor the case and report on any significant developments.


Posted in Access, copyright infringement, Daniel Morel, Fair Use, First Amendment rights, Legal, National Press Photographers Association, News Photography, NPPA, photographers, Photographers' Rights, photojournalism | 24 Comments »

24 Responses to “NPPA Joins in Brief Supporting Photographer in Pivotal Copyright Case”

  1.   قیمت بلیط هواپیما تهران نجف,بلیط هواپیما نجف,قیمت بلیط هواپیما نجف,بلیط هواپیما تهران نجف,بلیط تهران نجف,قیمت بلیط تهران نجف,پرواز تهران نجف Says:

    Magnificent beat ! I would like to apprentice at the same time as you amend your website, how can i subscribe for a blog site? The account aided me a applicable deal. I had been a little bit acquainted of this your broadcast offered vivid transparent idea

  2.   Andres Says:

    Hello, just wanted to say, I loved this article. It was funny.
    Keep on posting!

  3.   Marc Corcuera Says:

    Thanks Getty! We can’t wait to get commenced!

  4.   Tobias Brousard Says:

    This really answered my downside, thank you!

  5.   Bernard Czwakiel Says:

    This is such a fantastic idea. A friend of mine sent me your url. It’s such a superior way to engage readers offline and get physical mail which everyone loves. I may have to do this after my blog is up and running a bit more.

  6.   Hershel Buchsbaum Says:

    Oh my goodness! an amazing article dude. Thank you However I am experiencing situation with ur rss . Don�t know why Unable to subscribe to it. Is there anyone getting identical rss problem? Anyone who knows kindly respond. Thnkx

  7.   Habibi Says:

    I truly enjoy looking through on this web site, it has got good content. “One should die proudly when it is no longer possible to live proudly.” by Friedrich Wilhelm Nietzsche.

  8.   Habibi Says:

    Can I just now say such a relief to discover 1 who truly knows what theyre dealing with on-line. You in fact know how to bring a concern to light and earn it essential. Lots far more men and women have to appear at this and see why side with the story. I cant think youre not a lot more popular because you definitely develop the gift.

  9.   Habibi Says:


  10.   Ramonita Kovalaske Says:

    Thanks a lot…

  11.   Abram Bloem Says:

    Wow! Thank you! I always wanted to write on my website something like that. Can I take a fragment of your post to my site?

  12.   counseling in mumbai Says:

    Contact Us at :

  13.   Karl Joas Says:

    very nice inf0 keep it up thanx

  14.   art gallery in Kolkata Says:

    Contact Us at :

  15.   Ambrose Shed Says:

    Make sure you explain this FL statute with regard on the previously details:br /617.0802 Qualifications of /(one) Directors needs to be natural persons that are 18 ages of age or older but will need not be residents of the state or members on the corporation unless the content pieces of incorporation or bylaws so require. The content articles of incorporation or perhaps the bylaws may possibly prescribe added qualifications for /(2) Within the event the eligibility to serve like a member on the board of directors of a condominium association, cooperative association, homeowners’ association, or mobile home owners’ association is restricted to membership in this kind of association and membership is appurtenant to ownership of a unit, parcel, or mobile household, a grantor of a trust described in s. 733.707(3), or a beneficiary as defined in previous s. 737.303(4)(b) of a trust which owns a unit, parcel, or mobile property shall be deemed a member on the association and eligible to serve as being a director in the condominium association, cooperative association, homeowners’ association, or mobile household owners’ association, provided that reported beneficiary occupies the unit, parcel, or mobile dwelling.

  16.   name Says:

    presumably helping account for the sample’s layered, ripely fruit-toned depth. As most roasters know, combining two roast levels is a risky business if not ,

  17.   Florida Lock & Key Says:

    Florida Lock & Key 3620 Manatee Ave W Bradenton, FL 34201 (941) 748-5625

  18.   Anonymous Says:

    Fx buying and selling is the investing of forex in the foreign trade industry (Forex or Forex trading) which is a worldwide marketplace for the investing of forex in an aim to make earnings. The foreign trade market place establishes the relative worth of each and every currency with regard to one more forex. The pitfalls involved in forex trading is quite large due to lot of unpredictability, but a quantity of traders have made massive sums of cash in foreign exchange trading particularly Monthly bill Lipschitz, George Soros and Stanley Druckenmiller. It is regulated by the foreign exchange currency buying and selling board obtaining the requisite jurisdiction.

  19.   Vern Desalle Says:

    Superb Place.i appreciate present..even more hold out .. ;)

  20.   Marcella Mabrey Says:

    Planning to bang her is already implied.

  21.   Simon Cazorla Says:

    There is noticeably a bundle to know about this. I assume you made certain nice points in features also.

  22.   Referencement 417 Says:

    Great blog but honestly the sheer amount of Ads.

  23.   Modern Dining Room Says:


  24.   primary education Says:


Leave a Reply