A Tale of Two Cases: How Photographers Are Being Squeezed From All Sides

November 20th, 2013 by Mickey Osterreicher

Today was a picture perfect example of how photographers are being squeezed from all sides. On the front end photographers are being interfered with and arrested on an almost daily basis nationwide for doing nothing more than trying to do their jobs by photographing and recording matters of public concern on city streets.

In one such case a NYC Criminal Court jury acquitted photographer Jason Nicholas today on a misdemeanor count of Obstructing Governmental Administration. Mr. Nicholas was arrested in 2011 for allegedly interfering with NYNJ Port Authority Police while covering a news story. A previous trial resulted in a hung jury but the district attorney chose to re-try him. Afterwards Mr. Nicholas said, “this is a victory for us and a swift and resounding defeat for the police and prosecution!” ”Now maybe we can get this to stop on behalf of all journalists,” he added.

On the back end where photographers works are being used globally without their permission, Daniel Morel was sitting in a federal courtroom a few blocks away from Mr. Nicholas. He is pitted against Agence France Press (AFP) (and Getty Images) in a copyright infringement case. Read about this case along with updates here.

Liability for infringement has already been established. The only remaining defendants in the counterclaim case are AFP and Getty Images, as the other defendants have already settled with Mr. Morel.  All that is left for the jury to decide is how much each of them (AFP & Getty) must pay in damages. Click here for a running blog of the six (6) days of testimony.

Attorneys for both sides are expected to make their closing arguments tomorrow morning in the Southern District of New York Courthouse located at 40 Foley Square in New York City. Judge Nathan’s courtroom is on the 5th floor for those of you able to attend.

So on one day within a few blocks of each other I was able to view some of the major challenges facing photographers around the world and also witness how two of them chose to stand up for their rights and by so doing take a stand against those who would violate our constitutional and copyrights.


Posted in Access, AFP v Morel, Agence France-Presse, Assault on Photographers, contracts, copyright, copyright infringement, Daniel Morel, False Arrest, First Amendment, First Amendment rights, Fourth Amendment rights, Getty, Lawsuit, National Press Photographers Association, News Photography, Newsgathering, NPPA, photographers, Photographers' Rights, photojournalism, Police, Recording Police, retaliation for the exercise of First Amendment rights, social networking, Twitpic, Twitter | 39 Comments »

39 Responses to “A Tale of Two Cases: How Photographers Are Being Squeezed From All Sides”

  1.   instalacje elektryczne piaseczno Says:

    Excellent study, I just accepted this distinct on top of a new colleague who was simply liability somewhat inquiries in that. In addition to they emphatically purchased me lunchtime because I ran crossways it regarding him grin Consequently reasonable, i’ll rephrase that: Thanks pertaining to lunch! Whenever you’ve an victorious government you’ve got a dictatorship. by Badger Azines Truman.

  2.   Kasey Males Says:

    This site is certainly alternatively helpful considering that I am together with the second developing an online floral internet site in spite of the fact that I am only commencing out being a result it is truly relatively little, nothing by any means similar to this online internet site. Can website hyperlink to some from the posts suitable here because they are fairly. Many many thanks considerably. Zoey Olsen

  3.   Arron Menedez Says:

    Highly interesting write-up. Your point of view is extremely to the point and interesting. I’ll definitely be subscribing to your RSS or Atom. I really hope you will publish often on similar subjects. But I’m curious what your resources for your article are? Cheers.

  4.   Anja Whitecloud Says:

    I’d like to retire in the English countryside

  5.   Habibi Says:

    Outstanding post, I believe website owners should acquire a lot from this weblog its real user friendly. So much superb info on here :D.

  6.   Habibi Says:

    very good put up, i surely really like this web web site, maintain on it

  7.   Habibi Says:

    You’ve observed very intriguing points ! ps decent internet website.

  8.   Elias Delara Says:

    I really like your writing style, fantastic info , regards for putting up : D.. You made some decent points there. great terrific more please.

  9.   plan cul paris Says:

    Plan cul gratuit sur internet !

  10.   Abby Wolfinger Says:

    It is an Impala SS. The Biscayne and Bel Air were being not accessible to be a 2-door hardtop, along with the regular Impala experienced its nameplate to the rear quarter.

  11.   Keven Laggan Says:

    I like what you guys are up too. Such intelligent work and reporting! Carry on the superb works guys I

  12.   Joycelyn Plauche Says:

    The distinction between wines that rate at 96 and wines that rate at 98 are not likely to be distinguishable precisely on a regular basis. Yes, Tish, you are right. So what? Those are scores that tell me only one thing. The person who gave them loved those wines.

  13.   Florida Lock & Key Says:

    Florida Lock & Key 3620 Manatee Ave W Bradenton, FL 34201 (941) 748-5625

  14.   Laurence Jakubowski Says:

    I totally agree with what you are saying eventhough this short article is not suit to new WP :)

  15.   Gonzalo Pasierb Says:

    Yknow, I just checked out some of the info cards for the character bios that get unlocked as you progress the gunshot doctor guy on the boats supposed to be Scottish? I spent the whole game under the impression he was Irish.

  16.   Earleen Mordino Says:

    Fantastically fantastic bless you, It is my viewpoint your trusty followers may well want more information like this keep up the fantastic effort.

  17.   Marvis Casasola Says:

    It is ended up being busted throughout Ohio intended for drag-racing, I am able to proudly state i was the police officer when compared with took him or her straight into child custody soon after they ignored police arrest. While i seen they was leading to difficulty When i instantly named Obama and offered him or her my providers, he / she gladly accepted in addition to acquired myself within the following airfare for the ALL OF US.

  18. Says:

    Bring the spirit of spring into your wardrobe with
    Swatch watches. If there were ever to be a popular watch brand that’s beloved by both men and women, it would be Casio.
    99, a price reduced to 61% off the normal list price.

  19.   Maria Szmidt Says:

    Odd , your post turns up with a black color to it, what color is the primary color on your web site?

  20.   Dorine Says:

    It helps to have a think about what your general style and look is, before you search for your
    next watch. With the model GD910 LG is entering the wrist watch
    mobile phone market. But its silver-tone case and Michael
    Kors charm (with the initials MK) make it dressy enough for the office.

  21. Says:

    Watches that are too big or too small don’t do anyone any good.
    Watch making is an art in its own and there are masters
    in the field out there with wide collections of timepieces that
    speak about fashion. If you wear a Nixon watch, you are definitely going
    to stand out of all.

  22.   Allene Mcclamy Says:

    important post , really good perspective on the subject and very well written, this certainly has put a spin on my day, numerous thanks from the USA and retain up the good work

  23.   Engine Block Says:

    I enjoy, lead to I discovered just what I was looking for. You have ended my 4 day long hunt! God Bless you man. Have a nice day. Bye

  24.   interior decorating Says:

    I haven

  25.   fashion style Says:

    I haven

  26.   Sherika Says:

    Having seen people miraculously heal from all kinds of dis-ease through non-invasive methods, the woman passion right now is actually to help assist people become aware of exactly what it takes to be healthy.

  27.   Anonymous Says:


  28.   Muscle and Fitness Says:

    Hi, i think that i saw you visited my site thus i came to

  29.   Modern Furniture Says:


  30.   Colton Crocket Says:

    Bin Laden was taken out on Obama’s watch, and it galls conservatives that they cannot attack the POTUS for staying weak against foreign terrorist threats. n nHad this accomplishment been made when Bush was still President, Rove, Sununu, and other suitable wing blowhards could be singing his praises and hailing him being a genius for his military leadership and clandestine operation decision-making.

  31.   beautiful home Says:


  32.   Jeremy Lamudio Says:

    I am always looking online for posts that can aid me. Thanks!

  33.   Herma Bosarge Says:

    What an incredible concept to publicize climate change by using tasty,fresh pops that aid neighborhood farmers along with their produce!

  34.   david sills V steve clarkson Says:

    Thanks for the post. I thought it was awesome.

  35.   Newton Delahay Says:

    Love EarthTechling, glad to determine them on listed here. Nino and Patricia know their things!

  36.   Francisco Vinci Says:

    Interior and outside titles appear to generally be switched

  37.   gacukruhture Says:

    This really answered my problem, thank you!

  38.   Shanelle Ransome Says:

    I couldn

  39.   Party Dresses Says:

    Hello There. I found your blog using msn. This is a really well written article. I

Leave a Reply