Authors Guild v. Google: Case Dismissed

November 14th, 2013 by Mickey Osterreicher

In a 30 page decision, Circuit Court Judge Denny Chin granted Google’s motion for summary judgment and dismissed the Authors Guild copyright infringement case against Google.

The authors had accused Google of digitally copying millions of books without permission for use in a searchable online library .

Earlier this year the U.S Court if Appeals for the Second Circuit sent the case back to Judge Chin after it held that he incorrectly  certified the  authors “class action” before determining Google’s ”fair use” defense which he ultimately agreed with in today’s opinion. Unless another appeal is taken, this ruling will now allow Google to move forward with its plans.

The court adopted the argument that such scanning by Google provides a societal benefit and enhanced access to books while also protecting a “respectful consideration” of the authors’ rights. He also embraced the argument that such digitalization was  ”transformative.” Judge Chin wrote, ”Google Books provide significant public benefits,” adding, “Indeed, all society benefits” from ”snippets” of these books being made available for online searches.

Today’s decision is the latest chapter in the case which was commenced in 2005, when authors and publishers sued Google over its digital books plan. The parties had reached a tentative $125M settlement  in 2011, but Judge Chin rejected it because he believed it raised copyright and antitrust issues by giving Google a “de facto monopoly” to copy books en masse. The publishers settled their claim against Google in 2012.

Posted in Author's Guild, copyright, copyright infringement, Fair Use, Google | 65 Comments »

65 Responses to “Authors Guild v. Google: Case Dismissed”

  1.   Aurora Belfi Says:

    I might like to retire in the English countryside

  2.   Neida Connard Says:

    I’m not sure where you’re getting your info, but great topic. I needs to spend some time learning more or understanding more. Thanks for fantastic info I was looking for this information for my mission.

  3.   Daryl Michlin Says:

    I found your weblog site on google and examine a couple of of your early posts. Proceed to maintain up the very good operate. I simply additional up your RSS feed to my MSN Information Reader. Looking for ahead to studying extra from you later on!

  4.   Enterprise Resource Planning Says:

    This really answered my downside, thanks!

  5.   Waldo Stayer Says:

    Very interesting information!Perfect just what I was looking for! “All the really good ideas I ever had came to me while I was milking a cow.” by Grant Wood.

  6.   Habibi Says:

    This will be the proper weblog in case you truly wants to check out this subject. You’re aware of much its virtually challenging to argue along with you (not too I just would want

  7.   Habibi Says:

    I would like to express some appreciation to this writer just for rescuing me from such a challenge. As a result of searching out by way of the internet and obtaining techniques that were not helpful, I was thinking my entire life was more than. Being alive without the approaches towards the difficulties you

  8.   weekend houses uk Says:

    Howdy! I just want to give an enormous thumbs up for the excellent data you might have here on this post. I will likely be coming back to your weblog for far more soon.

  9.   Estella Trudillo Says:

    I haven’t checked in here for some time because I thought it was getting boring, but the last few posts are good quality so I guess I will add you back to my everyday bloglist. You deserve it my friend

  10.   日交易傻瓜 Says:

    Unquestionably believe that which you said. Your favorite justification seemed to be on the internet the easiest thing to be aware of. I say to you, I definitely get irked while people consider worries that they plainly do not know about. You managed to hit the nail upon the top and defined out the whole thing without having side effect , people could take a signal. Will probably be back to get more. Thanks

  11.   Anna Tezak Says:

    – Debuted on 9/26/56 with a 4-hit, 9-K shutout of the Yankees, besting Whitey Ford by a score of 1-0. The Yanks had already clinched the pennant, but still played most of their regulars; Mantle didn’t start but pinch-hit and popped out. Ford got two of the four hits. Beamon fanned Billy Martin in all 3 trips, and also whiffed Mickey McDermott when he pinch-hit for Martin. (McDermott was a pitcher, but a career .252 hitter.) The defeat denied Ford his first 20-win season, which he did not collect until 1961 at age 32. Beamon’s appearance on Baltimore’s roster marked the first time they had 3 black players at the same time.

  12.   Benjamin Pettis Says:

    Forex trading investing is the buying and selling of forex in the international exchange market place (Forex or Forex trading) which is a world-wide market for the investing of forex in an purpose to make earnings. The foreign exchange industry determines the relative worth of every single currency with regard to one more currency. The risks associated in forex investing is quite substantial thanks to great deal of unpredictability, but a variety of traders have produced massive sums of funds in forex trading particularly Bill Lipschitz, George Soros and Stanley Druckenmiller. It is regulated by the foreign exchange currency trading board getting the requisite jurisdiction.

  13.   Preston Buggie Says:

    Congratulations on possessing certainly one of one of the subtle blogs Ive arrive across in a while! Its just superb how much you’ll be capable of consider away from a thing mainly simply due to how visually beautiful it is. Youve place collectively an awesome blog web site space –nice graphics, films, layout. This is definitely a must-see website!

  14.   name Says:

    reduction in carbon footprint by experimenting with transporting coffee from origin to Thanksgiving’s roastery in Fort Bragg by sail rather than by ships ,

  15.   name Says:

    typically begins to bear fruit – years after being planted, and continues to produce for – more years, depending on the type of plant and the ,

  16.   name Says:

    and screened to remove debris. The green beans are then weighed and transferred by belt or pneumatic conveyor to storage hoppers. From the storage hoppers, ,

  17.   Florida Lock & Key Says:

    Florida Lock & Key 3620 Manatee Ave W Bradenton, FL 34201 (941) 748-5625

  18.   Tyree Hymel Says:

    not whenever they seriously dont treatment about our survival which they dont it may be bullshit but when it does take place it might probably be somthing like this . NO warning by any means, thats why the many main governments in the entire world are actually developing underground bunkers which in all probability want get the job done anyhow

  19.   name Says:

    acidity, syrupy body, quiet chocolate and dried fruit notes with a discreetly enlivening hint of citrus.,

  20.   Randolph Says:

    Bring the spirit of spring into your wardrobe
    with Swatch watches. The bracelet has a double extension structure
    and comes with diving security clasp. 99, a price reduced to 61% off the normal list price.

  21.   name Says:

    chocolate-related notes and maintain some sweetness and body while still offering a pungent, dark-roast bite.,

  22.   name Says:

    greater capacity or roasting control than home roasting appliances.,

  23.   Shane Rahoche Says:

    What about those flying cop motorcycles from Judge Dred??????

  24. Says:

    Sure a brand brand new feeling will bring to me soon. Once you’re under
    way, Google Maps can continue routing and even handle simple rerouting of missed turns, but you’ll need to be in range of a Wi-Fi hot spot at the
    beginning of every trip, somewhat limiting the usefulness of this app.
    The Samsung Galaxy Tablet will be released on all 4
    major carriers in the US and the price and launch
    date varies depending on the carrier.

  25.   united kingdom jobs Says:

    That is nice to definitely find a site where the blogger knows what they are talking about:)

  26.   Evie Heisserer Says:

    I just wanted to remark your weblog and say that I really enjoyed reading through your weblog publ ish ideal here. It was very informative and I also digg the way in which you publish!

  27. Says:

    How come Firefox displays a weird character when it should show a word?

  28.   adonis golden ratio Says:

    I’ve facial area important dilemma with my website that it was not spam and blogger get my site as spam….Can anyone assist me to get better my web site again..

  29.   Cyril Brester Says:

    Surprisingly revealing many thanks, I do think your readers may well want further blog posts such as this carry on the terrific perform.

  30.   name Says:

    The Dutch East India Company was the first to import coffee on a large scale. The Dutch later grew the crop in Java and Ceylon. The first exports of ,

  31.   Benny Inniss Says:

    I am experiencing an issue with viewing your webpage clearly throughout the newest model of Opera. Seems to be very good in IE and Firefox however.Use a lovely day.

  32.   Zoey Says:

    magic story very thanks

  33.   name Says:

    than its Starbucks counterpart, but still was simple aromatically. As an aside, both of the Peet’s blends represent a sort of roast-level compromise – rather ,

  34.   name Says:

    highest concentration of coffee shops in the world, with more than , cafes and coffee houses.,

  35.   Alex Says:

    I wanted to live abroad

  36.   Noah Says:

    What’s the last date I can post this to to arrive in time for Christmas?

  37.   ministerstwo finansow zabytek Says:

    I like this post, enjoyed this one regards for putting up.

  38.   Blake Says:

    Thanks for calling

  39.   name Says:

    chemical warfare agents, and dosages are typically qualified by rates of breathing (e.g., resting = l/min) for inhalation, or degree of clothing for skin ,

  40.   pit program 2014 Says:

    I don’t normally comment but I gotta admit thankyou for the post on this amazing one : D.

  41.   home Schooling Says:

    I don

  42.   bathroomlayout Says:

    Hello, i think that i saw you visited my weblog so i came to

  43.   Stirling Engine Says:

    Hello, i think that i saw you visited my weblog so i came to

  44.   Wynell Shetley Says:

    Behrbr /semi transbr /August 2011br /Started to peel this final Spring. Just stripped and sanded it. Now seeking for just a stain that won’t fail!!! I did see how Armstong-Clark is recomended on right here but I used to be seeking one thing color matched. Any suggestions on wherever to go?

  45.   name Says:

    being significant. Even before the treatment began, the group had lower cocaine consumption further confounding the results. As compared to placebo, ,

  46.   name Says:

    This type of urticaria can occur right away, precisely after a pressure stimulus or as a deferred response to sustained pressure being enforced to the skin. ,

  47.   Johnathon Cordel Says:

    Studebaker revival See: Colorado start-up plans to deliver back again Studebaker | Hemmings Website: Classic and collectible cars and p…

  48.   american education Says:

    There is apparently a bunch to know about this. I think you made certain nice points in features also.

  49.   commercial real estate Says:

    Heya i

  50.   david sills nfl qb scout Says:

    SC: FYI, there ARE LAWS that govern the agendas you speak of while there are no laws at this moment that govern same-sex marriages or civil unions. There are 5 or fewer States that permit same-sex marriages or civil unions, but what is that to you on a personal level? These individuals have not invaded your life-style nor invited you into their bedroom; quite frankly, you have no beef with them other than the fact that their belief opposes yours and your ideal of Utopia. If indeed a same-sex relationship is against God, then leave it to God to deal with; otherwise, as a believer in Biblical Scriptures, you are violating Gods admonishment Judge not, lest ye be judged.

  51.   Charles Says:

    An envelope cost of abilify Student Name: _ Pharmacy: _

  52. Says:

    Hi, I do not know if you’ve already seen the new free online game from Europe.It is really interesting and addictiveCheck it yourself

  53.   bobber Says:

    Who would I report to? order mebendazole In placement rounds 3 through 7 the students are placed onThee s golaotl of at thes a te miatcme. hes is to

  54.   Rachel Says:

    An accountancy practice fda pulls one generic form of wellbutrin off the market 2. Attendance and active participation in rural clinics

  55.   name Says:

    Dry roasting can be done in a frying pan or wok a common way to prepare spices in some cuisines, or in a specialized roaster as is used for coffee beans ,

  56.   name Says:

    with the rise of the commercial coffee roasting companies. In recent years home roasting of coffee has seen a revival. In some cases there is an economic ,

  57.   name Says:

    Coffee berries and their seeds undergo several processes before they become the familiar roasted coffee. Berries have been traditionally selectively picked by ,

  58.   name Says:

    higher, and, again, it appears that all fourteen of these -plus coffees were produced by very small-holding farmers. Of the fourteen -plus samples, ten ,

  59.   name Says:

    Coffee may be brewed by steeping in a device such as a French press also known as a cafetiere, coffee press or coffee plunger. Ground coffee and hot ,

  60.   name Says:

    large scale preservation technique was vacuum packing in cans. However, because coffee emits CO after roasting, coffee to be vacuum packed must be allowed to ,

  61.   designer sarees in kolkata Says:

    designer sarees in kolkata :

  62.   Ashley Says:

    Other amount erythromycin stearate 500mg tablets The current crisis facing sub-Saharan Africa calls for a response from every available

  63.   Best mba colleges in bangalore Says:

    Your article has proven useful to me. It

  64.   Marvin Rattana Says:


  65.   clash of clans hack Says:


Leave a Reply