UPDATE: AFP v Morel Copyright Infringement Case

January 16th, 2013 by Mickey Osterreicher and tagged , , , , , , , , ,

***** UPDATE 10/18/2013 – In a case already full of twists and turns, presiding U.S. District Judge Alison J. Nathan, had harsh words for the attorneys representing Daniel Morel in his copyright infringement lawsuit against remaining counterclaim defendants AFP and Getty. According to reports the counterclaim plaintiff’s attorneys Barbara Hoffman and Joseph T. Baio have attempted to involve the court in their dispute over Hoffman’s access to the terms of the confidential settlement agreement that was recently reached with the Washington Post (see update below).

Hoffman and Baio each sent letters to the court asserting their position (see Hoffman Letter and Baio Letter) In her one page Order addressing the “letter dispute,” Judge Nathan admonished the lawyers for having “failed to meet and confer in a professional and reasonable manner before burdening the court with this dispute.” She then ordered them to meet and confer “for no less than one hour in an effort to come to a reasonable and professional agreement. Failure to abide by this requirement may result in sanctions.”

As can be read in the dueling letters (above) Hoffman, who earlier represented Mr. Morel on a contingency fee basis, has claimed a charging lien on any settlement agreements. Baio, whose law firm, Willkie Farr & Gallagher, LLP, now represents Morel expressed concern about confidentiality terms.

In two other late developments, Roger Netzer, of the same law firm entered an appearance of counsel of record for Mr. Morel on October 17th and Matthew R. Farley filed a motion for admission pro hac vice (a legal term literally meaning “for this turn” and usually referring to a lawyer who has not been admitted to practice in that court but may be permitted to represent a party in that case).

The trial is still scheduled to begin on 11/12/2013.


****** UPDATE 10/3/2013 – This week the presiding judge dismissed claims against the Washington Post Co., one of the defendants in the copyright infringement case, after the parties reported they had reached an undisclosed settlement. In her two-page order, Judge Nathan dismissed the claims against the Post with prejudice and without costs, which means that neither party were responsible for paying the others’ costs or attorneys’ fees. The order also barred remaining defendants AFP and Getty from being able to deduct any payment of the Post settlement amount from any future award of damages to Morel.

The trial is scheduled to begin on 11/12/2013.


New York District Judge Alison J. Nathan has ruled (AFP-Morel Decision 01-14-13) that news service Agence France Presse (AFP) and The Washington Post Co (the Post) infringed upon photojournalist Daniel Morel’s copyright by their unauthorized use of his photos of the 2010 Haiti earthquake aftermath.

Mr. Morel had uploaded the photos in question to by linking them to his Twitter account because the country-wide devastation to electricity and Internet connections forced him to use this more public method. Further complicating the matter, shortly after Morel posted his pictures online they were reposted to the Twitter account of Lisandro Suero, who tweeted that he had exclusive photographs of the earthquakes. A number of agencies including AFP then credited Suero for the photos.

In the original Complaint, filed in 2010 AFP sought a declaratory judgment that it had not infringed upon Morel’s copyrights and included defamation claims against him as well. Morel then counter-claimed that AFP, the Post, Getty and other news organizations had distributed his images without his permission.

In its answer AFP argued that it was a third-party beneficiary of the license agreement between Morel and Twitter, by claiming that Twitter’s Terms of Service (TOS) granted it a license as one of Twitter’s “other users.”

“Based on the evidence presented to the Court the Twitter TOS do not provide AFP with an excuse for its conduct in this case,” the Court noted in finding that “The Twitter [terms of service] provide that users retain their rights to the content they post — with the exception of the license granted to Twitter and its partners — rebutting AFP’s claim that Twitter intended to confer a license on it to sell Morel’s photographs.”

In making its ruling the court observed that “the dispute between the parties with regard to liability for direct infringement turns on Counterclaim Defendants’ affirmative defenses, namely their claims that (1) by posting the Photos-at-Issue on TwitPic/Twitter, Morel granted them a license, (2) Getty is entitled to the benefit of a DMCA safe-harbor, and (3) Getty has not engaged in volitional conduct sufficient to impose liability.”

In an ironic twist this recent decision comes two years to the date after District Judge William H. Pauley III issued his Decision denying AFP’s motion to dismiss Morel’s counter-claim suit. In that earlier proceeding Judge Pauley also concluded that the express language of the Twitter and TwitPic TOS did not provide an express license that protected AFP.

In her well-reasoned 58 page decision Judge Nathan granted Morel partial summary judgment ruling that “AFP and the Post are liable for copyright infringement as to the Photos-at-Issue.” But the court rejected his “arguments regarding the scope of statutory damages available under the Copyright Act and DMCA.” The judge also denied motions for summary judgment with regard to whether the infringements were willful; as well as the “claims for contributory and vicarious copyright liability.”

Because there remain genuine issues of fact the Court denied Mr. Morel’s claim for summary judgment regarding DMCA violations and also limited his recovery under that Act should he prevail at trial. After careful analysis the Court also concluded “that any awards of statutory damages against AFP or Getty may not be multiplied based on the number of infringers with whom AFP or Getty is jointly and severally liable. Rather, AFP and Getty are, at most, each liable for a single statutory damages award per work infringed.”

Judge Nathan further rebuked AFP by stating “in making its arguments on summary judgment AFP wholly ignores those portions of the Twitter TOS that are directly contrary to its position, particularly those portions stating that ‘you retain your rights to any Content you submit, post or display’ and ‘what’s yours is yours – you own your content.’”

This case serves as a cautionary tale about just how important it is to read and understand any TOS before clicking “agree.” These were the Twitpic TOS at the time that Morel uploaded his images: “by submitting Content to Twitpic, you hereby grant Twitpic a worldwide, non-exclusive, royalty-free, sublicenseable and transferable license to use, reproduce, distribute, prepare derivative works of, display, and perform the Content in connection with the Service and Twitpic’s (and its successors’ and affiliates’) business, including without limitation for promoting and redistributing part or all of the Service (and derivative works thereof) in any media formats and through any media channels.” You should also read the current TOS which have been substantially modified, due in large part to this case.

Morel settled with counter-claim defendants ABC, CNN and CBS in 2011. A conference is set for February 1, 2013, at 4:00 pm to discuss further scheduling of this matter.


Update: Morel’s attorneys have released a press release, stating in part that “Although Judge Nathan rejected Morel’s legal theory entitling him to as much as one hundred twenty million dollars in statutory damages, Morel still hopes to win millions in damages following trial.”

Posted in AFP v Morel, Agence France-Presse, copyright, copyright infringement, Daniel Morel, Digital Millenium Copyright Act, Getty, photographers, Photographers' Rights, photojournalism, Twitpic, Twitter, Washington Post | 120 Comments »

120 Responses to “UPDATE: AFP v Morel Copyright Infringement Case”

  1.   Alan Henney Says:

    How does this differ from Facebook’s TOS?

  2.   The Jobs Board – A Powerful Jobs Promotions Website Says:

    Generally I don’t read post on blogs, but I wish to say that this write-up very pressured me to try and do it! Your writing taste has been surprised me. Thanks, very great post.

  3.   tavane grilate Says:

    you are really a excellent webmaster. The web site loading pace is amazing.
    It seems that you’re doing any unique trick. Furthermore, The contents are masterwork.
    you have performed a magnificent job on this matter!

  4.   wipDupViomi Says:

    A clean fast is better than a dirty breakfast. Jakendads

  5. Says:

    I like the helpful information you provide to your articles.
    I’ll bookmark your weblog and take a look at again here frequently.
    I’m relatively sure I’ll be told a lot of new stuff
    right here! Good luck for the next!

  6.   tavane false bucuresti Says:

    I enjoy what you guys are usually up too. This type of
    clever work and reporting! Keep up the fantastic works guys I’ve
    incorporated you guys to blogroll.

  7.   tavane false bucuresti Says:

    Wonderful article! That is the type of info that should be
    shared around the web. Disgrace on the seek engines for no longer positioning this post upper!
    Come on over and discuss with my web site . Thank
    you =)

  8.   Cristopher Zolondek Says:

    I am impressed with this internet site, genuinely I am a big fan.

  9.   Lue Robes Says:

    I am glad to be a visitor of this arrant internet site, appreciate it for this rare info!

  10.   Sydney Rastetter Says:

    Dead written content material, Really enjoyed studying.

  11.   Rhett Zhao Says:

    This sort of wanting to come to a difference in her or his lifestyle, initial typically Los angeles Excess weight weightloss scheme is a large running in as it reached that strive. weight loss

  12.   Reuben Cutty Says:

    I genuinely enjoy reading through on this web site, it has got fantastic articles. “The great secret of power is never to will to do more than you can accomplish.” by Henrik Ibsen.

  13.   Burt Slaubaugh Says:

    Rather than produce exactly the same old content you might have taken this topic to a entire new level. Kudos for not following the standard writing crowd.

  14.   Colby Esannason Says:

    certainly like your web-site however you need to check the spelling on quite a few of your posts. A number of them are rife with spelling issues and I to find it very troublesome to tell the reality however I’ll definitely come back again.

  15.   Trena Barrott Says:

    Thanks for helping out, superb information. “If at first you don’t succeed, find out if the loser gets anything.” by Bill Lyon.

  16.   Dion Zadorozny Says:

    If you continues to undecided: pick up your finest headphones, forehead to go and each Greatest coupe and enquire that would connect these items proper Zune possibly an iPod and view what one tunes easier to you in fact, moreover where vent creating you pleased much. You should are certain which happens to be perfect for you.

  17.   Willow Opielski Says:

    I came across this good from you out of sheer luck and never feel lucky enough to say also credit you for any job effectively done.

  18.   Marcelino Bonier Says:

    I surely did not realize that. Learnt some thing new these days! Thanks for that.

  19.   Cristopher Zolondek Says:

    you might have an excellent blog here! would you like to make some invite posts on my weblog?

  20.   Ed Rodes Says:

    It truly is extremely rare these days to uncover sites that provide info someone is seeking for. I am glad to see that your weblog share valued details that can aid to several scaners. thank and keep writing!

  21.   Rivka Guerero Says:

    I conceive you have noted some very interesting details , regards for the post.

  22.   Silvia Linan Says:

    This is really intriguing, I

  23.   Oliva Mountcastle Says:

    I wanted to thank you a great deal much more for this remarkable web-site you’ve designed here. It truly is full of helpful suggestions for those who are genuinely interested in this subject, specifically this extremely post. Your all really sweet plus thoughtful of others as nicely as reading your website posts is really a fantastic delight in my experience. And what a generous reward! Mary and I will definitely have enjoyable generating use of your guidelines in what we must do in several weeks. Our checklist is actually a mile long which means that your suggestions may possibly be put to excellent use.

  24.   Ami Hockaday Says:

    Loving the information on this web web site, you have done excellent job on the weblog posts.

  25.   Rachele Holler Says:

    I like this web blog very much so much wonderful information.

  26.   Catheryn Stayer Says:

    You are my aspiration, I possess few web logs and often run out from post :). “‘Tis the most tender part of love, each other to forgive.” by John Sheffield.

  27.   Sherman Rapacki Says:

    Deference to op, some superb selective details.

  28.   Randi Hiscox Says:

    Soon after study just several with the blog posts in your web site now, and I truly like your means of blogging. I bookmarked it to my bookmark web site listing and will probably be checking once more soon. Pls look at my web page as properly and let me know what you feel.

  29.   refMuffersRut Says:


  30.   Patricia Mencke Says:

    I like this post, enjoyed this one thankyou for posting.

  31.   Arie Jin Says:

    Excellent web site. Lots of useful info here. I am sending it to several buddies ans in addition sharing in delicious. And of course, thank you inside your sweat!

  32.   Dan Lose Says:

    You could surely see your enthusiasm inside the function you write. The world hopes for more passionate writers like you who aren

  33.   Kum Galante Says:

    You need to participate in a contest for among the very best blogs on the web. I will suggest this internet internet site!

  34.   Federico Veneman Says:

    hey, your internet website is superb. We do appreciate your work

  35.   Dede Hurns Says:

    I truly appreciate this post. I’ve been looking everywhere for this! Thank goodness I found it on Bing. You have made my day! Thanks again!

  36.   Mao Monfore Says:

    Thanks a lot for the helpful content. It is also my belief that mesothelioma cancer has an incredibly long latency time period, which means that symptoms of the disease might not exactly emerge right up until 30 to 50 years after the preliminary exposure to asbestos. Pleural mesothelioma, that is the most common variety and impacts the area around the lungs, could potentially cause shortness of breath, upper body pains, as well as a persistent coughing, which may bring about coughing up blood vessels.

  37.   Denver Netland Says:

    hello, i came in to learn about this topic, thanks alot. will put this website into my bookmarks.

  38.   Yolanda Goeman Says:

    I conceive you have observed some very interesting details , appreciate it for the post.

  39.   Fern Barness Says:

    Someone essentially assist to make seriously posts I’d state. That is the first time I frequented your web page and up to now? I surprised with the analysis you made to make this actual submit amazing. Wonderful task!

  40.   Nicholle Leising Says:

    Oh my goodness! an incredible article dude. Thank you However I’m experiencing difficulty with ur rss. Don know why Unable to subscribe to it. Is there anybody finding equivalent rss drawback? Anyone who knows kindly respond. Thnkx

  41.   Bret Mantyla Says:

    I like the valuable data you give inside your articles. I

  42.   Jerald Boushie Says:

    An fascinating discussion might be valued at comment. I do believe that you simply write read far more about this subject, it may possibly not often be a taboo topic but normally persons are too couple of to dicuss on such topics. To a higher. Cheers

  43.   Ericka Ellis Says:

    Cool post thanks! We feel your articles are wonderful and hope more soon. We love anything to do with word games/word play.

  44.   Willie Lemkau Says:

    This is really fascinating, I

  45.   Hong Adamos Says:

    I’ve been absent for some time, but now I remember why I used to love this web site. Thank you, I will try and check back more frequently. How frequently you update your web site?

  46.   Michale Burby Says:

    magnificent issues altogether, you just gained a logo new reader. What might you recommend in regards to your put up that you simply made some days ago? Any sure?

  47.   Loris Cusic Says:

    Thanks for blogging and i enjoy the blog posting so no public comments.,,,,,,,,,,,

  48.   Verda Archambeau Says:

    I see something really special in this website.

  49.   Gisele Bealmear Says:

    The Case For HIIT Cardio – Why You must Concider it

  50.   Burma Midget Says:

    Loving the info on this internet website, you have done excellent job on the weblog posts.

  51.   Morton Bueckers Says:


  52.   Janice Tonti Says:

    I gotta bookmark this internet internet site it seems very helpful invaluable

  53.   Caryl Burrichter Says:

    You really dealt with several engaging points in this article. I came across it by utilizing Bing and I

  54.   Romeo Dillabough Says:

    I regard something genuinely interesting about your web site so I saved to favorites.

  55.   Delpha Kinna Says:

    I like this internet site because so considerably valuable material on here : D.

  56.   Earl Vanderlaan Says:

    Some really great content on this internet site, thankyou for contribution.

  57.   Leif Trax Says:

    When I originally commented I clicked the -Notify me when new surveys are added- checkbox and today if a comment is added I’m four emails with the exact identical comment. Is there any way you are able to eliminate me from that service? Thanks!

  58.   Von Hartwick Says:

    Thankyou for helping out, excellent info.

  59.   Sergio Dehlinger Says:

    F*ckin? tremendous items here. I am quite satisfied to see your post. Thank you so much and i

  60.   Kandis Conzales Says:

    This is a nice weblog i ought to say, typically i don????t post comments on others???? blogs but would like to say that this post really forced me to do so!

  61.   Fritz Cabiness Says:

    I’m glad that it turned out so nicely and I hope it will continue inside the future because it truly is so worthwhile and meaningful towards the community.

  62.   Crystal Kitzerow Says:

    I certainly did not realize that. Learnt one thing new today! Thanks for that.

  63.   Kyong Lacrosse Says:

    Spot on with this write-up, I truly suppose this website needs rather more consideration. I

  64.   Will Beddome Says:

    Hello. remarkable job. I did not expect this. This is a fantastic story. Thanks!

  65.   Francisco Oshea Says:

    Just a quick hello and also to thank you for discussing your ideas on this web page. I wound up inside your weblog correct soon after researching physical fitness connected issues on Yahoo

  66.   Graham Eliott Says:

    Thank you for the good writeup. It in fact was a amusement account it. Look advanced to far added agreeable from you! By the way, how could we communicate?

  67.   Erasmo Haury Says:

    Respect to post author, some fantastic data .

  68.   Shannon Gramajo Says:

    Numerous thanks I ought say, impressed with your website. I will post this to my facebook wall.

  69.   Jena Drouin Says:

    You have brought up a very great points, thanks for the post.

  70.   Jerry Tarrance Says:

    Hey, just looking around some blogs, seems a pretty good platform you’re using. I

  71.   Lee Willimas Says:

    I really don

  72.   Madie Schumans Says:

    Good post. I learn some thing tougher on distinct blogs everyday. Most commonly it truly is stimulating to learn to read content material from other writers and exercise a specific thing there. I

  73.   Shawnee Nev Says:

    Yeah bookmaking this wasn

  74.   Luther Famiglietti Says:

    Sweet site, super layout, truly clean and utilize genial.

  75.   Raylene Turmel Says:

    Extremely fascinating details you’ve got mentioned, thanks for posting.

  76.   Hubert Alvero Says:

    Hello! I just want to give a huge thumbs up for the great info you might have here on this weblog. I will probably be coming back aimed at your web site for additional soon.

  77.   Kris Corcoran Says:

    I’m curious to uncover out what weblog platform you happen to be utilizing? I

  78.   Maximo Kristen Says:

    An interesting discussion is worth comment. I feel that you want to write far more on this matter, it might not be a taboo topic but normally individuals are not enough to speak on such topics. To the next. Cheers

  79.   Angelo Skrzypek Says:

    I like this web blog very much, Its a real nice berth to read and receive info. “What is a committee A group of the unwilling, picked from the unfit, to do the unnecessary.” by Richard Harkness.

  80.   Habibi Says:

    Wow! This can be 1 certain of the most helpful blogs We have ever arrive across on this subject. Truly Excellent. I

  81.   Jerold Gilruth Says:

    I’m glad to be a visitor of this thoroughgoing internet site !, appreciate it for this rare info !.

  82. Says:

    I think the admin of this web page is actually working hard in support
    of his web site, because here every information is quality based data.

  83.   Habibi Says:

    Great post, you have pointed out some fantastic details, I too conceive this s a quite amazing internet site.

  84.   Ahmad Beisel Says:

    However, how can we communicate?

  85.   Ursula Brislin Says:

    Aw, it was quite a good post. In notion I have to location in writing related to this furthermore – taking time and actual effort to create a really very good article

  86.   Dion Rabe Says:

    Thanks for yet another informative post. Exactly where else could anyone get that kind of info in such a easy to understand way of presentation.

  87.   Robbie Callander Says:

    Outstanding editorial! Would like took pleasure the specific following. I

  88.   Leonardo Lapuerta Says:

    And Im running from a normal users account with strict limitations, which I believe might be the limiting factor, but Im running the cmd as the system I am currently working on.

  89.   Brittni Gata Says:

    Deference to op, some superb entropy.

  90.   Yevette Waszak Says:

    Excellent read, I just passed this onto a colleague who was doing a little research on that. And he just bought me lunch as I found it for him smile So let me rephrase that: Thanks for lunch! “Curiosity will conquer fear even more than bravery will.” by James Stephens.

  91.   Cornell Reazer Says:

    Amazing this hit it at the dot we will post to Bebo and also Fb ?

  92.   Andrew Pettyjohn Says:

    Somebody necessarily help to make seriously articles I may state. That will be the extremely first time I frequented your web page and to this point? I surprised with the research you made to make this actual put up wonderful. Amazing task!

  93.   Laquita Regulski Says:

    This sort of in search of get the enhancements made on this special lifestyle and diet, begin your L. a. Shifting the pounds diet remedy can be a huge procedure into accesing which generally hope. weight loss

  94.   Sanjuanita Shongo Says:

    extremely good put up, i undoubtedly adore this internet web site, carry on it

  95.   Arletha Cicerchia Says:

    Appreciate it for helping out, superb details.

  96.   Isaias Rydolph Says:

    Exceptional weblog here! Also your web website loads up quick! What host are you using? Can I get your affiliate link to your host? I wish my internet site loaded up as rapidly as yours lol

  97.   Dudley Bowlick Says:

    some times its a pain in the ass to read what blog owners wrote but this website is really user pleasant!.

  98.   Desmond Haehn Says:

    If I should say something, then absolutely nothing will stop the chatter within

  99.   Garret Lannom Says:

    There exist a couple of many different distinct levels among the California Weight loss program and each and every a person is pretty critical. You are procedure stands out as the the actual giving up with all of the power. weight loss

  100.   Bertha Mades Says:

    I’m so grateful for this post and thanks such a whole lot for sharing it with us.

  101.   Manuel Ahlo Says:


  102.   Liberty Shandy Says:

    Oh my goodness! an exceptional post dude. Thank you Nonetheless I

  103.   Juan Chandronnait Says:

    I’ll immediately grasp your rss as I can not in finding your e-mail subscription link or newsletter service. Do you have any? Kindly let me realize in order that I may just subscribe. Thanks.

  104.   Farrah Tringali Says:

    Very interesting information!Perfect just what I was looking for! “Love endures only when the lovers love many things together and not merely each other.” by Walter Lippmann.

  105.   Suzanna Humphrey Says:

    Super-Duper blog! I am loving it!! Will be back later to read some more. I am taking your feeds also

  106.   Kathi Meisler Says:

    Great post, you have pointed out some wonderful details, I besides think this is a very excellent website.

  107.   Cameron Gilday Says:

    You got a really excellent website, Gladiola I discovered it by way of yahoo.

  108.   Quintin Sita Says:

    I like this internet site really much so considerably wonderful information.

  109.   Lillia Hodd Says:


  110.   Ka Posse Says:

    I should express my passion for your generosity for men and women who should have assistance with this specific niche. Your quite own commitment to finding the message up and down had become extraordinarily valuable and have constantly permitted associates like me to get to their ambitions. The helpful guideline denotes so much a person like me and additionally to my colleagues. Thanks a ton; from each one of us.

  111.   Bill Oka Says:


  112.   Fran Nulty Says:

    Thank you for writing this tremendous top quality write-up. The info in this material confirms my point of view and you actually laid it out well. I could never have written an write-up this good.

  113.   Chanell Lindman Says:

    I wanted to thank you for this excellent read!! I definitely enjoying every small bit of it I’ve you bookmarked to take a look at new stuff you post

  114.   Shirley Shankman Says:

    I like the valuable info you provide within your articles. I

  115.   Neda Palek Says:

    I’d personally also like to state that most individuals that find themselves devoid of health insurance are normally students, self-employed and those that are not working. More than half of those uninsured are under the age of Thirty five. They do not come to feel they are wanting health insurance simply because they’re young plus healthy. Their own income is usually spent on homes, food, and entertainment. A lot of people that do work either entire or in their free time are not made available insurance by their work so they move without due to the rising expense of health insurance in the us. Thanks for the strategies you share through this web site.

  116.   Samual Scercy Says:

    Hello! I basically would wish to offer a huge thumbs up for that wonderful info you

  117.   Mathilde Crumble Says:

    Job scope at significant scale lies for forensic science experts at crime laboratories rub by city, county or state governments. The other region exactly exactly where an individual seeking for a career in forensic science can secure job are Federal agencies including the Departments of Justice, Federal Bureau of Investigation, Secret Service, Drug Enforcement Administration, Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms, Postal Inspection Service and other crucial departments, private labs and university laboratories is also a location of function for Forensic Science technician.

  118.   Monte Lemmonds Says:

    Then after a genuinely long time, a decade possibly, it is possible to become a captain.

  119.   Dwayne Buist Says:

    I got what you intend, saved to fav, quite nice website .

  120.   Devin Says:

    Wow! This can be one particular of the most beneficial blogs We’ve ever arrive across on this subject. Basically Magnificent. I’m also a specialist in this topic so I can understand your effort.

Leave a Reply